Earlier this year, I had the opportunity to spend just under a week with Alvaro Uribe, former president of Colombia and architect of arguably the most dramatic turn-around in the history of the drug war. This month, I have a magazine piece out in the Washington Monthly profiling President Uribe--and looking at what lessons from Colombia's experience are being applied to Mexico. I argue that, because Mexico and Colombia are so fundamentally different, the Uribe model won't necessarily work in Mexico. In fact, the reasons it won't are the same reasons that the strategy is starting to falter in Colombia as well... here's a sample:

Colombia’s incredible turnaround and the strategy credited with bringing it about have become not only a rare success story in the drug war, but also its most formidable brand and export. The governments of Mexico and several other Central American countries that have been plunged into violent confrontation with drug gangs have tried assiduously to replicate their South American peer’s strategy. ...

There are two problems, however. The first is that none of these places, despite years of effort, has yet seen the kind of transformation that Uribe brought about in Colombia. In fact, so far, the momentum runs in the opposite direction. The case of Mexico is particularly striking; roughly 50,000 lives have been lost since the country’s experiment with a Colombian-style militarized drug war began in 2006. ...

The second problem is that, in Colombia itself, Uribe’s strategy has reached a point of sharply diminishing returns. Having largely defeated what was, at bottom, a sweeping leftist insurgency against the state, and having decapitated a relatively cohesive paramilitary force, Colombia now faces a hydra-headed, apolitical, essentially criminal set of groups vying for turf and control over what’s left of the drug trade. None of these groups is as powerful as its precursors, but nor do they seem to be susceptible to the same strategic countermeasures. And violence is starting to drift upward....

The idea that sheer military might and political will can beat back the narcotics trade is a powerful one. Uribe’s ideas and tactics have spread to every corner of the globe marred by the drug trade and nearly every institution that is fighting organized crime. Which means that if those ideas are misguided—or, perhaps more dangerously, misunderstood— then so too is nearly every fight in the drug war.

Read the whole piece in the Washington Monthly.

Originally posted at www.elizabeth-dickinson.com