Al AswanyBachrach The Editors Hakakian Kara-Murza Kirchick Krastev Marlowe Muravchik Ozel  Zantovsky

World Affairs Summer 2008

Roya Hakakian

Roya Hakakian: Under the Veil

Roya Hakakian on the Middle East, Iran and issues related to international relations, foreign policy and human rights.
Title: The End of Martyrdom
Keywords:

February 11, 2010 did not turn out to be the end of the regime in Tehran. But in time, it may prove to have been the end of something even more important for Iranians, and perhaps, for the Shiite culture. It was the end of an ancient love affair with death. It was the end of blind sacrifice—of martyrdom.

We Iranians have always cherished blood. If there were no fresh supplies to stir us, the old were reliably in our memory. Year after year, the Ashura mourners, grieving the martyrdom of Imam Hussein in 680 AD, passed through the streets, beating their chests—the clinking of their chains ominously echoing in the air. The few euphoric among them would strike their own heads with daggers. Anyone who drew blood was applauded. The view of the sacred crimson shade dared and inspired others to follow suit. The emergency rooms were always flooded during the holiday.

In 1978, red handprints dotted the walls of Tehran. And what it conveyed to a nation that was on the verge of erupting was far more powerful than any words or slogans. That year, every shirt imbrued with blood was held above the heads of the demonstrating crowds not simply as a flag, but a talisman. We have always worshipped blood.

It was this quality that Ayatollah Khomeini exploited to drag on the war with Iraq, long after Iran had driven Saddam’s army from the territories it had initially captured. “Our leader is that thirteen-year-old boy who straps grenades around his waist and throws himself in the way of the Iraqi tanks,” he declared before the audience that was always weeping in his presence. The leader’s endorsement, and a plastic key to open the gates of paradise, was all that droves of young men needed to step on their own death by rushing headlong into the Iraqi minefields.

Even secular and Marxist groups were bent on this kind of blind sacrifice. In the early 1980s, several of them, a Maoist group named Sarbedaran among them, staged doomed uprisings throughout Iran that could only lead to their imminent deaths and executions, as they did. In busy bazaars and bus terminals in those early years, members of the Islamic opposition group, the People’s Mujahideen of Iran, also staged random, singular acts of protest by shouting anti-ayatollah slogans, then followed with swallowing cyanide pills and dying before the stunned public. Freud must have been looking down upon Iran, pointing to us as “Exhibit A” in his defense of Thanatos.

The national drive for death is a tradition that predates Ayatollah Khomeini. Sacrifice is that primordial mud in which the Iranian psyche was cast. It has been the cornerstone of our literature. The self, the material body, have always been shunned. To annihilate them is, what our best poets suggest, the way to reach the light, the beloved, and, according to some, God. It’s the untranslatable in our celebrated poetry. It’s only the grains of love, not the death that flow through the strainer of translation. It’s that filtered verse with which English speakers are so enamored.

I’ve long contended that Persian, with its hundred ways of expressing the tired Anglo-Saxon I love you, is the language of affection. But what goes unsaid is that 99 of those ways either meander or cut through the idea of death—of dying for the sake of the beloved. This comingling is why the Persian brand of love is so intense, so rife with all the enchanting marks of legends and fairytales. The sheer focus on the other, the readiness to deny the self for the sake of the other, accounts for some of what makes Iranians so lovable, yet so unprepared for the 21st century.

What is ingrained in the American psyche, the a priori of this culture, was something I finally grasped 10 years after coming to America –that to live life required one to embrace life, not death; that one’s material existence as manifested in one’s body was to be celebrated; that the self was not something to be ashamed of; that the pronoun “I” had a rightful place in one’s prose. On the eleventh year, I applied for U.S. citizenship. On the twelfth, I began to vote. To extend the Descartesian principle: I arrived at self, therefore I arrived at democracy.

Last Thursday, the regime had armed itself to the teeth, unleashed its thugs onto the streets, and bused in thousands more protesting day-laborers from the far-flung corners of the country into the capital. Tehran was under siege by strangers. They outnumbered and out-powered the peaceful activists. Instead of coming out and protesting, and clearly rushing to their own death as their national inner circuitry would have charged them to, the Green demonstrators kept inert. After all, the migrants would have to return home. And between the births and deaths of the 12 imams—which Iranians celebrate as steadfastly as the pagan events on the calendar—there were numerous reasons to take to the streets again in the near future.

When it comes to the Green Movement, there are the grand signs –a million people’s march on the street—that need no interpreting. But there are also the subtler, the subterranean ones that do. What’s most promising about the Green Movement is its desire to be bloodless, to self-preserve, and its wish to live for a cause, not die for it. This isn’t to say that the movement isn’t facing obstacles—the greatest being its inability to communicate with its leaders and foot soldiers. Yet despite all the odds, the restraint, the composure by which the Green activists have conducted themselves thus far is both admirable and unprecedented. This surely is no consolation to those who are consumed by the more immediate threats of Iran’s regime. But for those less intoxicated by “yellowcake,” last Thursday revealed signs of a different kind of promise –of the birth of self, the will to live, the longstanding morbid drive disappearing —the stuff that enduring peace is made of.

mindy bricker


Comments:
Milad
February 17, 2010 01:19:46 AM
I wish you had bothered to read Sharaiti on Shahadat before you allow yourself to write this piece.
duvar
February 18, 2010 02:32:33 PM
Thank you for wonderful insight. Hope that your positivism concerning the Green movement is right. It seems that the same rush of Martyrdom-ism going to once again cripple the Iranian green middle class too.
Hugh shull
February 18, 2010 08:48:04 PM
Isn't it Shariati you pedant?
@Milad
February 18, 2010 10:15:42 PM
You must work for the regime. I read Shariati. Insipid nonsense.
@Milad
February 19, 2010 06:25:41 AM
You must work for the regime. I read Shariati. Insipid nonsense.
Hugh shull
February 20, 2010 05:55:41 PM
Isn't it Shariati you pedant?
macy
February 23, 2010 10:14:54 AM
I must say that you articulate yourself really nicely but the fact that you chose to only see iranians in blood baths while you forgot all about a good majority of christians during the middle ages who believed in sacrificing themselves for Jesus which some do still live by those practices plus the Romeo & Juliet love story which is the epidemy of classical true love in the west!!!! As for Green, how could we who believe in living, democracy and love of life, possibly want the likes of the 4 Green reps to still lead us and like a herd of sheep go along with it? Green signifies them and it is a shame that iranians who live abroad are so very homesick to carry on with their own perspective whereas there is a "TRUE" frame of reference to all of these GREEN reps doings, past actions and movement for power!!!
sayghal
February 23, 2010 10:39:10 PM
When was the last time you visited Iran? Have you ever talk with the young generation who are living in Iran ? and do you ever been as poor as 75 per sent of Iranian people? Have you lived there under contorol of using your bedroom without privacy and have you ever been taken to Vozara court for your make up or your dress an hundreds more issu I wounder if you are believing in human rights ....hope you do
February 23, 2010 10:57:20 PM
Ms. Hakakian, we must not forget how deeply the concept of "Martyrdom" is ingrained in every culture, beyond religious values and beliefs. Green movement in Iran has not been bloodless. Unfortunately, everytime it has gained momentum has been indeed because of the innocent lives perished during the protests. As much as I wish I could share your optimism, although too idealistic and somewhat naive, my heart aches to see that the price any nation who is being under such horrific tyrany and dictatorship ends up to pay, is destined to be, their blood. The rulling regime in Iran wouldn't be shaken at its core otherwise.
maziar Irani
February 23, 2010 11:52:31 PM
Aside from the fact that Greens already have 100 or more martyrs, what does the REFORMERS screw up on 22 Bahman has to do with martyrdom? Highly illogical article, I am sorry to say.
Nilsson
February 27, 2010 12:58:36 PM
Usual maudlin outpouring from an exile. They have to sing the tunes their sponsors in foreign countries like to hear: in this case the sponsors being chiefly another small tribe embedded in our body politic but looking elsewhere. If the USA still took seriously the Founders' stern injunction not to meddle in the affairs of other countries, we wouldn't have to put up with such stuff. People who are the 'outs' in their own countries-- and how come The People haven't come close to overthrowing the mullahs as they did 'our guy', the Shah?-- should be grateful for sanctuary. Quit agitating to involve us in their screw-ups. America First, Last and Everywhere In Between!
Nilsson
February 27, 2010 01:01:41 PM
This woman's a Jewess, for pity's sake! All ME polls suggest that most Muslim women are very happy to dress conservatively and want more, not less, sharia law. At best Ms Hakakian is a useful idiot of Zionist determination to knock out a regional rival to Israel. Anyway, it's no damn business of America's how foreigners dress.
nobody you know
March 2, 2010 10:26:15 AM
After reading you article and all the comments, Do you understand why why we deserve this regim

Post a comment:

Verify the text in the image
WA Blogland

©2010 American Peace Society · 1319 Eighteenth Street, NW, Washington, DC · 20036 · Web@WorldAffairsJournal.org

Untitled Document